Skip to content

The Short Answer

ExpressVPN is the better VPN overall, scoring 9.5/10 vs Surfshark's 9.3/10. It wins 5 of 6 individual test categories and is particularly strong for streaming.

EX
ExpressVPNWinner
9.5/10 — Excellent
Surfshark logo
Surfshark
9.3/10 — Excellent
1

At a Glance

Spec
EX
ExpressVPN
Surfshark logo
Surfshark
Overall Score9.5/109.3/10
Starting Price$6.67/mo$1.99/mo
Servers3,000+3,200+
Countries105100
Devices8Unlimited
Best ForStreamingBest value
2

Score Breakdown

Each category is scored from 1–10 based on our independent testing criteria.

Speed

ExpressVPN wins
EX
ExpressVPN
9.7

Excellent

Surfshark logo
Surfshark
9.2

Excellent

🔒

Security

ExpressVPN wins
EX
ExpressVPN
9.5

Excellent

Surfshark logo
Surfshark
9.3

Excellent

Ease of Use

ExpressVPN wins
EX
ExpressVPN
9.8

Excellent

Surfshark logo
Surfshark
9.4

Excellent

💰

Value

Surfshark wins
EX
ExpressVPN
8.5

Very Good

Surfshark logo
Surfshark
9.9

Excellent

📺

Streaming

ExpressVPN wins
EX
ExpressVPN
9.9

Excellent

Surfshark logo
Surfshark
9.1

Excellent

🛡️

Privacy

ExpressVPN wins
EX
ExpressVPN
9.3

Excellent

Surfshark logo
Surfshark
9.2

Excellent

Category Wins
ExpressVPN: 5Surfshark: 1
3

Feature Comparison

FeatureExpressVPNSurfshark
Overall Score9.59.3
Speed9.79.2
Security9.59.3
Ease of Use9.89.4
Value8.59.9
Servers3,000+3,200+
Countries105100
Devices8Unlimited
Starting Price$6.67/mo$1.99/mo
4

Pricing

EX
ExpressVPN
$6.67/mo
Coupon: EVEXPRESS
Get ExpressVPN
Better Value
Surfshark logo
Surfshark
$1.99/mo
Coupon: EVSURF82
Get Surfshark
5

Pros & Cons

EX

ExpressVPN

Excellent9.5/10

9.5
Strengths
  • Best streaming VPN — unblocks Netflix in 22 regions
  • Servers in 105 countries (widest coverage)
  • Lightway protocol for blazing speeds
  • RAM-only TrustedServer technology
Weaknesses
  • More expensive than competitors at full price
  • No ad blocker included
  • Based in British Virgin Islands (ownership concerns)
Surfshark logo

Surfshark

Excellent9.3/10

9.3
Strengths
  • Unlimited simultaneous devices
  • Lowest price at $1.99/month (82% off)
  • CleanWeb ad and malware blocker
  • MultiHop double-VPN for extra privacy
Weaknesses
  • Slightly slower than NordVPN and ExpressVPN
  • Smaller server network (3,200 vs 5,400)
  • No dedicated IP option
6

Final Verdict

After testing both VPNs across 6 key categories, ExpressVPN is the stronger choice for most users. It scored higher overall (9.5 vs 9.3) and won 5 individual categories.

That said, Surfshark is still a solid choice, especially if you prioritize best value. Both are well above average.

More Comparisons

How we test: Every VPN is independently tested across 50+ criteria including real-world speed tests, DNS/IP leak checks, streaming unblock rates, and logging policy analysis. Read our full methodology →